Tajima’s Win in the Courts
| Practically every major
equipment innovation
used by embroidery
professionals
worldwide has come
out of the R&D labs
and manufacturing
divisions of Tajima. |
That’s why this past fall’s U.S. District Court
patent infringement win for Tajima against
Feiya America, the U.S. arm of a Chinese
manufacturer of embroidery machines, was
so critical. It was another clear indication that rights holders of intellectual
capital such as
Tajima will continue
to be protected both
domestically and internationally.
The particular patent
infringements
that Tajima pursued
through the legal system
amounted to eight major innovations that were copied without
permission by Feiya. These included:
- • Patent # 4943906 Issued on July 24, 1990
- • Patent # 4960061 Issued on October 2, 1990
- • Patent # 5001996 Issued on March 26, 1991
- • Patent # 5065682 Issued on November 19, 1991
- • Patent # 5261338 Issued on November 16, 1993
- • Patent # 5553560 Issued on September 10, 1996
- • Patent # 5655471 Issued on August 12, 1997
- • Patent # 5809918 Issued on September 22, 1998
| … it is critical that
industry innovators
such as Tajima be
protected, if only to
make it worthwhile for
further investment in
new technologies that
increase productivity
and capabilities, and
save costs…
|
Practically every major equipment innovation used by
embroidery professionals worldwide has come out of the R&D labs
and manufacturing divisions of Tajima, and in fact the company
owns over 170 international patents. Together, these patents
represent some of the best known and most important innovations
in the history of electronic embroidery. For example, the ones
cited above include
advances such as the
Tajima Control Panel
with “F” function key;
real time display of
embroidery during the
actual sewing; pack
setting; editing data
during embroidery
including order of color
change, reducing or
enlarging embroidery
designs, design repeat and more; one-touch Wide Cap Frame;
Wide-Cap Drive Ring, an integral part of the Tajima Wide-Cap
System; the Middle Thread Guide with Thread Take Up Lever that
vastly improves sewing quality with a variety of threads; the Take Up Lever Guide that prevents threads from tangling; and the
Tajima Frame Driving System. Many major manufacturers respect
these patents by having cross licensing and royalty arrangements
with Tajima in order to use Tajima technology in their machines,
and in turn Tajima has licensed these technologies to competitors
to broaden the benefit to the market while making its fair share
of profit off of the investment in R&D. However, Chinese
manufacturers have no such relationships with Tajima, and
have ignored repeated requests for negotiation. As an ongoing
business strategy that apparently is yielding significant results,
Tajima is investigating the unauthorized usage by Chinese
manufacturers of what seems to be the Tajima high speed
sequins attachment device, as well as other infringements.
What This Means for the
Embroidery Professional
Just like in other industries, it is critical that industry innovators
such as Tajima be protected, if only to make it worthwhile for
further investment in new technologies that increase productivity
and capabilities, and save costs... providing greater opportunities
for the industry as a whole. This is the clear benefit from a
decision such as the one handed down to Feiya and why the
majority of companies that are using stolen technologies should
be very concerned that payback is coming rapidly... as delivered
by the courts. And what can you do? Very simple: make sure you
are purchasing equipment, parts and software only from legal,
authorized dealers. Not only is it the right behavior from both a
legal and moral standpoint, but it will benefit your future business
and protect the health of the industry in which you have placed
your livelihood and the well being of your family.